When fifteen-year-old Lucy claims to have encountered a mysterious woman in the restroom of a small Southern grocery store, her extraordinary story leaves everyone puzzled. The stranger knew things she shouldn't have known, offered unusual words of wisdom, and vanished without a trace. As Lucy's protective older sister and two store employees debate whether the encounter was coincidence, imagination, or something miraculous, their differing beliefs lead to moments of humor, doubt, and unexpected understanding. In the Sweet Buy and Bye is a thought-provoking four-character comedy-drama about faith, skepticism, and the possibility of finding miracles in the most unlikely places.